I think the paps and BCs should be redone, I kinda like the others =p

I know this would cause a TON of work for poor Xy, but I would love to see his artwork compaired to Carni's BEFORE the new images are put into comission. I love Carni's pups (The JRT being my favorite) but if Xy's are a better representation of the breeds, or are cuter/more alert/more breed charactieristic, whatever, then I think it would only be fair to have Xy's art displayed for ALL puppies.

I think the BC, JRT, and Corgi need to be re-done because they are so smooth, simple, and perfect looking when they should have more fluff and fur instead of flat, lifeless fur. I like how the corgi is playing, the the smile on it looks a little fake. The JRT doesn't look that good in the way it's lying down, it looks a little more like a stuffed animal. The BC looks like it's posing when it should be more playful like all the other puppy images. <br /> <br /> I liked the Papillon a lot.<br /> <br /> I like the idea of this specific post. It gets more specific opinions out like mine, and it makes it so people can see what needs to be changed and exactly what could be worked on. :)

BC and Paps. All the rest look alert and expressive as a puppy should be.

I love the way the old pups are done, my favorite the Jack Russle Terrier. But honestly the BC pup could look like to it would be moving and having fun. I also want to see what Xylax has in store for making the new pups. The sheltie pup now has alot of character and I think, that the Pap should really just change. I LOVE the others. Now thst is just my opinion

I only think the Pap should be redone. (: I love all of the others!

I say border puppy and pap. Need a little more detailed expressive work..

I was thinking, maybe we should have a choice. Because some users are really attached to the breeds puppy image. What if, Xylax DID redo the puppies, for it seems that the poll he is winning, BUT, you could choose the puppy image you wanted to use on the dogs page. I am megaly attached to Carnis pap images, so I think this might be nice for the users who don't want to see the images go. What does everyone else think?

i'm not sure? I think the BC pup should be redone, but i'm just not sure what the others would look like if they were to be redone.

BC could use some work. Looks stiff..overall just doesn't look like there was much effort put into it. Pap, not liking the stance. Corgi need to be a smidgen longer and it's head is too big.