What was the use before? The 5-10-10 is kinda overpriced.

If something like this were moved to random events with 20 consecutive uses, I think it would have to be a separate item and introduced as an RE alone in the first place.<br /> <br /> Otherwise the main flaw is that there are 23,816 fish oils in current existence and most of them belong to a handful of users who have stocked up. To suddenly remove them from the shop now, change the use, and move it to RE only would most likely be on the level of "completely unfair" to the rest of the populace.<br /> <br /> I personally don't think it is essential to have this item, and the whole heartache caused by not being able to use it in a powering manner has made it become almost regrettable introducing the item to begin with bugged or not, if the perspective can be understood.<br /> <br /> I feel it is bargaining on what was someone's good will and intention.<br /> <br /> Such an item already exists in the form of the magical rubber ball, which can be used nonstop, but is balanced through its price and availability. <br /> <br /> Aside from personality perfection (which can be trialed) there would be no sense buying the magical rubber ball item.

20 uses would be limited, the limit would be 20 uses.

I think by unlimited, they meant that it remains as is, no removal of hunger, but still 20 uses per bottle.<br /> <br /> If it is only obtained through a random event, fewer bottles would be on the site. Less would be available. I think it is an easy solution.

I outlined why 20 uses would be disastrous, imagine what would happen if it was unlimited uses.

How would it be disastrous?<br /> <br /> Even if someone got 2-3 bottles a month, through random events, that is less uses than per day per dog. As it now stands one dog can use Fish oil 90 times in a 30 day month at 3x per day.<br /> <br /> If it remained unlimited in uses, but obtained only through random event, even if you go 3 bottles in a month, it is still just 60 uses in that month.

I'm not a fan of that, that would still be disastrous. Some people get RE companions a couple times a month.

How about it has unlimited uses, but only obtainable through RE?

not fond of the RE idea but a limit raise would be awesome

What about leaving the fish oil script as is, but making it obtainable ONLY as a random event?